Aug
How are instant payments impacting SMBs in the US? A peek into healthcare, transport and more
Instant payments offer SMBs several advantages, particularly in certain industries including healthcare, transportation and logistics.


Have you noticed the growing trend of small and medium-sized businesses (SMBs) adding “credit card convenience fees” lately? This surcharge, typically a percentage of the transaction amount, is often presented as a way for merchants to offset the costs that are associated with credit card processing.
The proliferation of credit card convenience fees at small businesses isn’t just an annoyance for consumers — it’s a red flag signaling a systemic imbalance in the payments landscape. While merchants bemoan the erosion of profits due to high processing fees, they often overlook the historical significance of credit cards: they once empowered small businesses by expanding payment options and providing much-needed transparency for finances.
However, the initial honeymoon phase has faded, replaced by the harsh realities of delayed settlements, unpredictable cash flow, and the ever-looming threat of chargebacks. This, coupled with the hidden costs of handling cash, paints a picture of small businesses caught between a rock and a hard place.
Credit vs. Cash: A Tug-of-War with No Winners
The current payment landscape forces small businesses into a constant tug-of-war between cards and cash, with neither option providing a truly satisfactory solution.
- Credit Cards: While convenient and secure, credit cards inflict a financial toll on businesses. The average processing fee ranges from 1.5% to 3.5%1, with additional costs for certain card types and processing methods. Delayed settlements, which can take days, further exacerbate cash flow challenges, especially for businesses operating on tight margins. Moreover, chargebacks and fraud represent a growing concern, with studies indicating that 33% of small businesses have been severely impacted.
- Cash: Though cash offers immediate access to funds and eliminates transaction fees, it’s far from a perfect solution. The “cost of cash,” which includes security risks, labor-intensive handling, and banking fees, can range from 4-15%2 of the cash received. This hidden expense, coupled with the inconvenience and declining acceptance of cash in an increasingly digital world, makes it an impractical long-term solution for most businesses.
5 Key Advantages of Instant Payments for SMBs
The limitations of traditional payment methods underscore a need for a more agile and efficient solution. Instant payments, also known as real-time payments (RTPs) are one solution that is gaining popularity among SMBs around the world. By enabling funds to be transferred between bank accounts within seconds — and which can be done 24/7 — instant payments address the pain points of both credit cards and cash, creating an increasingly attractive scenario for small businesses.
Instant payments are also interesting because they refer to a payment characteristic (instant), not a particular payment method, rail or provider. In most cases around the world, instant payments run on bank rails, offered by banks and fintechs connecting to those rails. In the US, these would be Same Day ACH or the emergent FedNow rails. Increasingly, however, instant payments are offered by card networks—Visa’s fast payment product, Visa Direct, rose 41% in number of transactions in Q3 FY2024.3 Closed-loop networks, such as Venmo, CashApp and PayPal, can also settle funds instantly. Fintechs and payment providers thus have a wide variety of instant payment rails to choose from, and SMBs can embed instant payments across various areas of their payment value chain—to collect payment from customers, to pay employees and contractors, and/or to pay invoices.
To illustrate, instant payments offer a multitude of benefits that can fuel SMB growth and innovation:
Cash-Flow Optimization: Real-time settlement empowers businesses to manage expenses, seize growth opportunities, and navigate unexpected financial challenges with confidence. The immediacy of funds can be a lifeline for small businesses, especially during economic downturns or seasonal fluctuations.
Cost Reductions: Transaction fees for instant payments are typically lower than credit card fees, leading to healthier profit margins and increased financial flexibility for SMB owners.
Elevated Customer Experience: By offering an alternative payment method, businesses can enhance capture new consumer groups, particularly younger consumers who have shown some aversion to credit cards (due to risk of over indebtedness)4 and in favor of UX-rich mobile payment options.
Innovation & Expansion: The speed and efficiency of instant payments can increase small businesses’ margins, helping them to explore new revenue streams, expand into new markets, and embrace innovative business models.
Business Operations: Faster access to merchant funds allows businesses to address immediate needs, such as payroll, inventory purchases, and unexpected expenses, promoting financial flexibility.
Real-World Applications: Instant Payments Across Industries
Instant payments are already making a difference in specific industries. Recent data from the Real-Time Payments Barometer Report highlights the healthcare industry’s preference for real-time payments, with 66% of healthcare provider SMBs using real-time rails (including debit, instant PayPal, and account-to-account transfers), indicating a strong preference for instant settlement5. Additionally, 74% of transportation SMBs in the US have sent or received instant payments in the past year.6 Let’s explore some more examples of industries adopting instant payments:
Transportation & Logistics: Truckers can receive payment on delivery, improving drivers’ financial stability, reducing downtime and enabling them to get on the road faster, and increasing productivity for the entire logistics chain.
Professional Services: Instant payments facilitate quick and easy invoicing and payment collection, improving cash flow and reducing administrative overhead for service providers.
Supply Chain & Logistics: Real-time payments can optimize supply chain operations by enabling faster settlement of invoices, improving supplier relationships, and reducing the risk of late payments.
Construction: Milestone-based payments provide contractors with predictable cash flow, reducing project delays and improving financial stability.
Hospitality: Restaurant tip payments empower staff with immediate access to their earnings, boosting morale and retention.
Gig Economy: Instant payments empower freelancers and gig workers to receive payments immediately upon completion of work, enhancing their financial stability and independence.
How Instant Payments Benefit Payments Ecosystem Players
Merchants: Instant payments enhance their cash flows, reduce costs, and provide a superior customer experience. Merchants can explore integrating instant payment solutions with their existing accounting and ERP systems for seamless automation and financial visibility.
Fintechs: They can leverage the power of instant payments to develop innovative payment solutions that address the evolving needs of businesses and consumers. Fintechs can also collaborate with financial institutions to accelerate adoption and drive industry-wide transformation.
Financial Institutions: Instant payment capabilities can help them attract and retain customers, increase their transaction volumes, and position themselves as leaders in the digital payments landscape. Financial institutions can partner with fintechs to expand their offerings and deliver cutting-edge solutions.
The Future is Now: Embracing the Instant Payments Revolution
The era of instant payments is upon us. The benefits are clear, the potential is immense, and the time to act is now. By embracing this transformative technology, businesses can unlock new levels of financial agility, customer satisfaction, and competitive advantage. As we navigate the ever-changing landscape of finance, one thing is certain: the future belongs to those who adapt and innovate. Instant payments are not just a trend, they are a fundamental shift in how we transact — and those who embrace them will shape the future of commerce.
About the Author
Marcia Klingensmith, known in the industry as the “Instant Payments Maven”, is a FinTech Consultant with a passion for innovation in the payments landscape. With over 20 years of experience driving innovation at Fortune 500 companies like Bank of America, Wells Fargo, Visa, and LexisNexis Risk Solutions, Marcia has a proven track record of leading teams and bringing groundbreaking products & services to market.
Her deep expertise spans instant payments, cross-border transactions, and the future of money. Marcia is a trusted advisor who helps financial institutions navigate the ever-evolving world of payments. She is committed to promoting conversations that push the boundaries of financial technology and empowers businesses to leverage its potential for growth.
Keep up to date with our e-commerce, payments and crypto insights:
Sources
- Credit Card Processing Fees (2024 Guide), Forbes, March 7, 2024. ↩︎
- Cash vs. Credit: Which Should You Accept for Your Small Business?, The Bottom Line, July 31, 2020. ↩︎
- Visa ↩︎
- Fast Company, 2024. “GenZ’s growing credit card debit problem, and how to fix it.” ↩︎
- Small Business Real-Time Payments Barometer, Healthcare Edition, PYMNTS, April 2024. ↩︎
- “Small Business Fleets Like Sending Instant Payments,” PYMTS Intelligence, June 14, 2024. ↩︎

